How to Succeed in BS/MD Interviews: Traditional Interviews, MMIs, and Common Mistakes

As a former medical school admissions committee member who now works closely with students interviewing for BS/MD programs, I have sat on both sides of the table more times than I can count. Once you land the interview, everyone is academically qualified. This is the stage where most decisions are actually made.

Here is how to approach BS/MD interviews, including both traditional interviews and MMIs.

The Interview Is a Fit Test, Not an IQ Test

Interviewers are not trying to assess how smart you are. Your grades and test scores already demonstrated that. Everyone invited to interview for BS/MD programs and medical schools has already been deemed academically capable of succeeding in the program. Applicants with academic concerns are not invited to interview.

What interviewers are actually evaluating is your maturity, communication skills, self-awareness, motivation for medicine, and whether they can envision you as both a future physician and a student in their program. If you sound rehearsed, robotic, or like you memorized answers from Reddit or forums, it works against you. The strongest candidates come across as thoughtful, reflective, and human.

Because the interview is a fit assessment, when asked “tell me about yourself,” you should not spend several minutes reciting your CV. Your interviewer has already reviewed it and will reference it during the conversation as needed. Instead, focus on sharing where you are from and the environment you grew up in, how you initially became interested in medicine, what you have been doing recently, and then end by mentioning a hobby or two that you genuinely enjoy. This creates an opportunity to build rapport. Some interviewers will take that opening and explore it with you, and if they do, let the conversation flow naturally.

Traditional Interviews: Master Your Story

In traditional one-on-one or panel interviews, you should be able to clearly and confidently answer why you want to pursue medicine, why you are interested in a BS/MD pathway, why you are drawn to that specific program, what your strengths and weaknesses are, and what areas of medicine currently interest you.

Your answers must be fully consistent with your application. If you state that a patient interaction changed your life, expect detailed follow-up questions. Interviewers probe for authenticity and depth. A common mistake is giving answers that sound impressive but are generic. Specificity matters. Refer to real moments, real people, real challenges, and clearly explain what you learned from those experiences.

It is also important not to oversell certainty. Programs do not expect a 17-year-old to know their exact subspecialty, but they do want to see emerging interests and intellectual curiosity. Humility and openness are viewed very positively.

You must also be familiar with every document you submitted, including essays and activities, as interviewers may ask about any part of your application. Not recognizing what they are referring to or appearing unfamiliar with your own materials can significantly hurt your interview evaluation.

Additionally, be prepared with thoughtful questions if you are asked whether you have any. Ask questions that are specific, relevant to your interests, appropriate for that interviewer to answer, and demonstrate that you have researched the program. For example, asking about a particular research pathway or curricular feature that aligns with your background is far stronger than asking generic questions. Not having any questions is a great way to reflect your lack of interest in the program and ultimately tank your score.

While there are many nuances to interviewing, these are the most critical points to master.

MMIs: Structure Beats Brilliance

Many BS/MD programs now use Multiple Mini Interviews, which often feel unfamiliar and intimidating to students. The reality is that MMIs are very learnable. They are designed to assess ethical reasoning, empathy, communication under pressure, and the ability to consider multiple perspectives.

A strong MMI response usually follows a clear structure. You should acknowledge the dilemma presented, identify the relevant stakeholders, discuss the competing values and challenges on each side, and explain how you would approach the situation in a thoughtful and reasoned way.

You are not graded on having the correct answer. You are not a medical student or physician, and you are not expected to possess advanced medical knowledge or deep expertise in medical ethics. What is being evaluated is how you think, how you process information, and how you communicate your reasoning. The goal of the exercise is to walk the interviewer through your decision-making process. Taking a brief pause to think is completely acceptable. Rambling or talking in circles is not.

Be Warm, Not Perfect

One of the most common misconceptions is that you need to be flawless. You do not. Programs would much rather interview someone who is genuine, kind, reflective, and coachable than someone who is technically perfect on paper but emotionally flat.

Make eye contact, be polite to everyone you encounter, and treat each interviewer and staff member with respect. Admissions committees pay attention to all aspects of your conduct, not just your formal responses.

Preparation Should Build Confidence, Not Scripts

Effective interview preparation does not involve memorizing answers. It involves understanding your own story, practicing how to communicate clearly under pressure, becoming comfortable with follow-up questions, and learning how to structure ethical and behavioral responses. When you truly understand who you are and why you are pursuing this path, the interview becomes far less intimidating.

BS/MD interviews are intense because the stakes are high, but they are also your opportunity to show who you are beyond the transcript and CV. If you are preparing for an upcoming interview and would like targeted feedback, mock interviews, or MMI preparation, feel free to comment or email success@admitmd.com to set up a free consultation.

How We Help Our Clients